Small SUVs Remain a Big Source of Dissatisfaction

Toyota’s brand new Corolla Cross could not have come soon enough as the smaller C-HR is the least liked vehicle in the entire auto industry for the second year in a row according to Consumer Reports’ latest survey.

The website once again polled its members to gauge their level of satisfaction toward their vehicle, asking them whether they would buy the same model in the future—an indication that their expectations are met.

For 2022, the top 10 least satisfying vehicles include seven subcompact SUVs and crossovers, one compact SUV and two compact sedans. Here’s the list, with the percentage of owners who would buy the same model again:

  1. Toyota C-HR – 29%
  2. Ford EcoSport – 30%
  3. Chevrolet Trax – 37%
  4. Infiniti Q50 – 40%
  5. Nissan Qashqai – 42%
  6. Infiniti QX50 – 46%
  7. Jeep Compass – 46%
  8. Jeep Renegade – 46%
  9. Cadillac XT4 – 47%
  10. Kia Forte – 47%

Interestingly, six of those also made the list in 2021, namely the C-HR, EcoSport, Trax, Q50, QX50 and Compass.

Photo: Ford

The small SUVs identified here prove how big a gap there is between the segment’s best (Subaru Crosstrek, Mazda CX-30, Kia Seltos, Hyundai Kona) and worst contenders. We know the EcoSport won’t return after 2022, while the C-HR (doomed by the lack of AWD) and Trax may be living on borrowed time, as well.

In many cases, owners report disappointing power, quality and space, and simply not getting their money’s worth.

Nissan/Infiniti continues to struggle with three models in the top 10. The redesigned Qashqai has yet to show up in North America, while the latest QX50 is a commercial failure. The Forte is anything but, however, ranking among the best-selling cars in Canada and the U.S. for a number of years.

As for Jeep, the Compass and Renegade are generally panned for their low value and fuel economy, sub-par reliability and lack of comfort. Plus, they don’t seem to fit with the brand’s upmarket strategy of late, which involves classy, premium vehicles such as the new Grand Cherokee, Wagoneer and Grand Wagoneer.

Watch: 2022 Toyota Corolla Cross is Bound to Become a Hit

Share on Facebook

More on the subject

NewsCompact SUVs Struggle Mightily in IIHS’ New Side Crash Test
The U.S. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has completed new, tougher side crash tests to address higher-speed crashes that continue to cause fatalities and found out that 19 out of 20 compact SUVs failed to earn a “Good” overall rating. The lone exception? The 2021 Mazda CX-5 . Nine …
NewsFord EcoSport to be Discontinued in Mid-2022
The Ford EcoSport is one of the least liked SUVs in North America for many reasons. Now we’ve learned the company is about to put it out of its misery, with exports to the U.S. and Canada ending in mid-2022. This comes on the heels of Ford’s decision to shut …
Test Drives2021 Nissan Kicks: Winning Formula
The Nissan Kicks is labelled and advertised as an SUV, with the company emphasizing its “truck-like” attributes, but in reality it’s nothing more than a new-look Versa hatchback with a taller profile. It has what many people want in a city car—cheap price, small size, good manoeuverability and high fuel …
Test Drives2022 Jeep Compass: Indecent Proposal
Despite SUVs being extremely popular, Jeep has a tough time selling its smaller models including the Cherokee , Renegade and Compass . The last one didn’t even manage to top 6,000 units sold in Canada last year. The company introduced a new generation for 2017, and now comes a mid-cycle …
NewsThe Car Guide's Best Buys for 2022: Nissan Kicks
Every year, The Car Guide unveils a list of Best Buys covering all the different vehicle categories in the industry. Urban crossovers are small utility vehicles that aren’t really SUVs. Many of them don’t even offer the option of all-wheel drive. And yet we see a lot of them on …
NewsChevrolet Trax, Buick Encore Reportedly Dead After 2022
Once popular but now seriously outmatched, the Chevrolet Trax and Buick Encore will end their production this summer and won’t be back after the 2022 model year, GM Authority reports. Just over a year ago, the same media outlet hinted that a replacement for the Encore was coming based on …
NewsChevrolet Trax to Get Second Generation, Debut Planned for This Year
A few weeks ago, reports indicated that the Chevrolet Trax and Buick Encore would end their production this summer and wouldn’t be back after the 2022 model year. As it turns out, that was only half the truth. The current-generation models will indeed retire, but now the automaker is saying …
Test Drives2022 Toyota C-HR: Looks Aren't Everything
It’s true: We consume mostly with our eyes. First impressions are main in seconds the moment our eyes land on any given object. How does it make us feel as soon as we look at it? Is it attractive? Repulsive? Funny? Scary? Looks carry a huge amount of weight in …
Pre-owned vehiclesIs the Cadillac XT4 a Good Choice?
Wanting to attract new young customers with a humbler budget, many luxury car brands have been rushing to introduce new small SUVs on the market over the last few years. Among them, there’s the Cadillac XT4 . Positioned under the XT5 and launched four years ago as a 2019 model, …
New Models2024 Chevrolet Trax is Completely Transformed, Goes FWD-Only
Following a one-year hiatus (there is no 2023 model), the Chevrolet Trax will return for 2024 with a second generation that’s completely transformed and much more likely to attract today’s young drivers with a focus on style and technology. The Trax will resume its position as Chevy’s entry-level crossover below …
NewsRefreshed 2024 Cadillac XT4 Gets 33 Inches of Displays
All of GM’s small crossovers are refreshed and improved for the 2024 model year. Hot on the heels of the Chevrolet Trailblazer (and Trax ) and the Buick Encore GX , it’s now the Cadillac XT4 ’s time to shine. Returning with the same three trim levels (Luxury, Premium Luxury, …
First Drives2024 Chevrolet Trax: Meet the Cruze 3.0
The original Chevrolet Trax (2013-2022) ended a long and mostly forgettable career by watching the fresher and larger Trailblazer steal whatever thunder it had left. Following a one-year hiatus, the Trax is back and completely transformed, and if it were carrying any other name, you’d think it was a brand …
NewsPrepare to Kiss the Nissan Qashqai Goodbye
While we’re still awaiting an official confirmation from Nissan Canada, it sure looks like 2023 will be the final year for the Qashqai in North America, meaning we won’t ever get the next-generation model that launched in Europe and Asia over a year ago. Remember, Nissan first eliminated its small …