All-Wheel Drive vs. Winter Tires: Which One is Best?

Winter tires are mandatory in Quebec (Dec.1-Mar.15) and British Columbia (Oct.1-Apr.30), but not in other Canadian provinces. And yet, their safety benefits over all-season tires have been demonstrated many times over.

Now, a lot of drivers across the country are arguing that all-wheel drive is more effective than winter tires when it comes to tackling snow and ice.

A little while ago, the team at Tyre Reviews attempted to settle the debate by doing a comparison with two identical MINI Countrymans—one with AWD and all-season tires and another with FWD and winter tires.

During the acceleration tests, the AWD-equipped model proved quicker off the line and at higher speeds. Similarly, it spent less time exiting corners than the other vehicle, even when going a bit sideways, thanks to all four wheels converting traction into acceleration.

Photo: Tyre Reviews

On the other hand, the FWD-equipped model on winter tires achieved much shorter braking distances, whether on snow or ice. It also displayed more control and predictable grip when attacking corners.

The verdict? All-wheel drive is certainly helpful—and more fun—during winter. However, in normal driving conditions where braking performance and predictable handling matter more than the ability to speed up, winter tires have the edge regardless of the number of drive wheels.

Enjoy the cold season and drive safe, everyone!

Share on Facebook

More on the subject

TiresWinter Tire Usage Outside of Quebec is Increasing
Outside Quebec, where winter tires are mandated by law, winter tire usage is up from 65 percent last year to 69 percent this year, according to a new Leger survey commissioned by the Tire and Rubber Association of Canada (TRAC). In fact, 7 percent of drivers in the rest of …
TiresTop 10: Best Winter Tires for Cars and Small SUVs, 2021-2022
Setting up our winter tire evaluations at the end of last winter wasn’t easy due to the various COVID-19 measures. With a curfew still in effect, we had little time during the day to get to our locations. Furthermore, we had to move some of the testing to the Outaouais …
NewsWhat Are All-Weather Tires?
In partnership with A new type of tire product called “all-weather” has grown in popularity over the last few years. These tires, which adorn the mountain and snowflake pictogram, are approved for winter but can also be used all year. They have nothing to do with conventional all-season tires.
Tires8 Great Tips and Reminders for Winter Tire Buyers
October is typically a good time to perform fall maintenance and prepare your vehicle for the cold season, including scheduling an appointment to have your winter tires installed. Car owners in need of a new set of tires shouldn’t waste any time, especially this year. As previously reported, the tire …
Features and TipsShould You Put Nitrogen in Your Tires?
We’ll say it again: improperly inflated tires can have a significant impact on your driving, your safety, and your fuel consumption, not to mention the resulting premature wear. In Canada, an estimated 25% of all road vehicles have at least one tire with a pressure that’s too low by 20% …
Features and TipsTire Change: Beware of the Speed Rating!
Your summer tires are worn out and you’re shopping for new ones? Or maybe you like to get things done ahead of time and are already preparing for the cold season? In either case, we invite you to read some of the articles we’ve published to help you make the …
Features and TipsHow to Get Rid of Your Old Tires?
Did you change your car’s tires recently? Kudos of you did, because they’re essential for your safety on the road. Now, what should you do with your old tires? Of course, if you think they are not too worn and can be used for one more season, you can try …
RecallsThousands of Michelin Tires Recalled for Lack of Winter Readiness
Forgive us for talking about winter tires when spring is in full swing, but a new recall by Michelin leaves us no choice. As you know, all tires marked with a three-peak mountain snowflake symbol (3PMS) must meet safety and winter traction requirements as established by Transport Canada. Ironically, these …
TiresBest Winter Tires for 2023-2024: Top Picks and Recommendations
Depending on where you live in Canada, winter tires may or may not be mandatory for a certain part of the year. Regardless, they have proven to outperform all-season and all-weather tires when temperatures drop below 7 degrees Celsius. And if you need a new set, it’s best to shop …
TiresIs Climate Change Making Winter Tires More Vital? Survey Says Yes
Extreme winter weather events related to climate change have made winter tires more important than ever according to 76 percent of Canadian motorists polled by the Tire and Rubber Association of Canada (TRAC). “It seems Canadian drivers are recognizing the changing weather patterns brought about by climate change,” says TRAC …