New Study Says PHEVs Are Much Dirtier Than Advertised

Spurred by recent investigations into the real-world performance of plug-in hybrid vehicles (PHEV) in Europe and China, a new study by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) suggests these vehicles fail to live up to their potential.

The main reason? Drivers don’t plug them nearly as often as they should.

Based on self-reported fuel economy figures from the website and data for engine-off distances traveled collected by the California Bureau of Automotive Repair, the ICCT found that real-world zero-emission trips may be 26-56 percent shorter than what official EV range estimates say.

Consequently, these vehicles burn 42-67 percent more fuel, on average, than is advertised in their EPA ratings in the U.S. It’s reasonable to assume the numbers would be similar in Canada.

Photo: Hyundai

“There is a risk that PHEVs will be used by manufacturers for compliance with future regulations, although they do not reduce emissions in real-world operation,” the ICCT study claims, while insisting that more data collection could provide greater precision and clarity.

Compared to regular hybrids, PHEVs must be systematically plugged in when not in use in order to maximize zero-emission operation. But unlike fully electric vehicles, many PHEV drivers don’t develop the habit because they know they can always count on the combustion engine whenever the battery runs empty.

Photo: Julien Amado

So why buy a PHEV in the first place, especially considering the higher prices? Good question. Government incentives certainly play a part as they sometimes bring PHEVs pretty close to the price of their regular hybrid counterparts.

The ICCT offers a few solutions, such as setting minimum electric range requirements for PHEVs to qualify for those rebates or adjusting the rebates based on real-world usage through on-board diagnostic reporting requirements. Meanwhile, automakers could incentivize regular charging by assisting with home charger installation and by actively reporting cost of driving to users, the report notes.

Share on Facebook

More on the subject

New Models2023 Dodge Hornet: A New PHEV Crossover is Born
After pushing the Journey into retirement in 2020, a void was created in Dodge's catalogue with no compact SUV to take its place. The automaker created a candidate to fill the position – a new arrival that was unveiled during Dodge Speed Week: the 2023 Hornet. The name rings a …
ElectricMore EV, PHEV Models Now Eligible to Federal Rebate
Starting Monday, April 25, the Canadian government’s Incentives for Zero-Emission Vehicles Program (iZEV), which grants rebates of up to $5,000, will be expanded to include the purchase of additional vehicle models popular with Canadians, such as SUVs, light-duty pickup trucks and minivans. The announcement was made on Earth Day, fittingly, …
NewsStudy: Most Cars Are Left Unused 95 Percent of the Year
While new vehicle sales increased nearly 7 percent in 2021 , a study by Turo Canada in partnership with Léger shows that a majority spend a heck of a lot more time parked than on the go. According to the popular carsharing platform’s first annual Car Ownership Index , 83 …