Hydrogen Power? Not So Fast!

For one reason or another, some people are fiercely opposed to electric cars, contending that converting the current network would be too drastic and that it would be much easier to transition to hydrogen.

Hydrogen-powered cars also have electric motors, but unlike electric cars, which power their motors using electricity from the batteries, they use hydrogen gas that has been compressed on board to generate electricity.

When your hydrogen tank runs empty, just stop at a gas station to fill up. It’s that simple. No need for a major system overhaul; it’s just a matter of adding hydrogen filling stations to existing gas stations.

But not so fast...

Installing these devices isn’t as easy as it sounds, and that’s not the only problem. The real hiccup in this plan lies at the very heart of the hydrogen-powered car itself: hydrogen.

There’s hydrogen everywhere. As the most abundant element in the universe, we don’t have to worry about where to find it. However, it has to be chemically separated and compressed, as hydrogen is rarely found in a pure state.

The environmental costs associated with extracting, shipping and compressing hydrogen make it three times less efficient from an ecological standpoint than pure electricity. In other words, even though hydrogen is cleaner than gasoline, exploiting it is not as sustainable as the electric alternative.

While Toyota and Honda are getting into hydrogen, Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche and Audi, to name but four, are following in the tracks of Tesla and Chevrolet by sticking with electricity.

Hydrogen-powered vehicles have some good qualities, but electric cars are much more like to save our civilization.

Share on Facebook

More on the subject

ElectricThe Electric Car: Not a Recent Invention
With the growing interest in electric cars, you might think that this type of technology is something new. After all, electric vehicles have only been made possible by recent advances in the fields of computers and batteries, right? Wrong! Miniature electric motors made their first appearances in the early 1800s, …
ElectricThe Electric Car: Not Ready for Primetime!
Automotive journalists are currently divided into two camps. Some see the arrival of the electric car as a real blessing, a gift from the gods comparable to the invention of penicillin or electricity. The other, more prudent camp is waiting in the wings, claiming that today’s world isn’t ready to …
Hydrogen-powered fuel cellChevrolet Colorado ZH2: Hydrogen for the U.S. Army
For the general public, there aren't a lot of advantages to choosing a hydrogen-powered vehicle over an electric car: the refuelling infrastructure isn't that great, and total driving range is not that impressive yet. However, for the U.S. Army, this technology offers some notable advantages, striking a nice balance between …
ElectricElectric Cars and Car Sharing: The Perfect Pair
If current trends are an indicator, electric cars will make up a large proportion of the vehicles on the road in the next few years. At the same time, car sharing programs are gaining in popularity, with businesses like Car2Go and Communauto growing across the province. The idea behind car …
ElectricElectric Cars: Better Batteries Are the Answer
With federal and provincial governments looking to turn buyers on to electric cars, an interesting market is opening up for automakers. There are two obstacles, however, that are putting the breaks on the widespread adoption of electric vehicles: high prices and the poor operating range of most batteries. Even though …