2017 Kia Forte Sedan: Jack of All Trades, Master of None

Strong points
  • Great new style
  • Well designed cabin
  • Efficient infotainment system
  • Fuel efficient Atkinson engine
  • Improved automatic gearbox
Weak points
  • Low resale value
  • Not a terribly dynamic ride
  • No integrated Apple CarPlay
Full report

As SUVs have become more popular, compacts have become less so, but they remain sought-after just the same, as evidenced by sales of the Civic, Elantra, Corolla and Mazda3. Given that they are relatively inexpensive, however, they are not exactly cash cows for manufacturers compared to other vehicle types.

Still, every manufacturer is wise to maintain a presence in this category. And with every passing generation, this segment is improving at an astonishing rate. Having owned a 2007 Corolla in 2009, I can tell you that this little car, when compared to its contemporaries, is disturbingly archaic.

In this market where compacts offer more and more, positioning their products properly means everything to manufacturers. When you think Toyota Corolla, you think reliability and resale value. When you think Mazda3, you think of fun, passion and design. When you think Civic, you think performance, carefree car and safe purchase. When you think Elantra, you think a lot of options for the asking price.

When you think Forte, umm… what exactly do you think of? Good question! A car that is available in sedan, five-door and coupe versions with various engines casts a wide net. To hear the manufacturer tell it, it combines performance, comfort, luxury, equipment, reliability, initial quality and more. Can a car manage to bring all of these elements together to create the perfect car? A bold gamble, especially considering that jacks of all trades are very often masters of none.

Far from a makeover for 2017

We made our way to Monterrey in northeastern Mexico to visit a new, gigantic plant constructed in just 14 months. Within the next few months, it should produce nearly 400 000 cars per year: the Forte, the Rio, and another mystery car—perhaps the next Soul?

But we’ll talk about the plant another time. The main reason for our visit was to see this Forte because Hyundai (Kia’s sister company) has a new Elantra for 2017, which means that Kia has to do the same for its compact.

Photo: Marc-André Gauthier

Except that it turns out that its new Forte isn’t really new after all. Rather, it’s an ever-so-slightly modified version of the previous version.

What’s new for 2017? Two major things: goodbye 1.8-litre engine, hello 2.0-litre four-cylinder Atkinson found in the Elantra. Otherwise, the bumpers have been modified to appear more modern and refined.

Inside, there are a few esthetic changes and a whole whack of new technology. The Forte sedan is also available, depending on the version you choose, with a driving aid system that keeps you in the middle of your lane. It’s like a mini Tesla Autopilot setup, except that you can’t let go of the steering wheel.

The six-speed automatic gearbox has also been improved, making it more docile and adding plates in the torque converter.

You can’t sacrifice quality

Kia is one of the brands that, year after year, stands out for initial product quality according to J.D. Power. We have to admit, the Forte, as diverse as its lineup is, delivers great quality.

When you get inside, the materials appear to be good quality and the assembly solid.

The spacious seats are great, and even more so since they are comfortable thanks to the cushioning.

But there’s just no passion at the wheel. The Forte5 SX with the 1.6-litre turbo engine is very good, though. The sedan version offers two engines: the Atkinson four with 147 horsepower and 132 lb.-ft. of torque in the LX, and the good old GDI four, also a two-litre with 173 horsepower and 154 lb.-ft. of torque in the other variants.

The Atkinson engine, which replaces the 1.8-litre engine, has very similar power and at a combined average of 7.5 L/100 km, its fuel economy is a little better. The more powerful 2.0-litre GDI offers a combined fuel consumption of 8.2 L/100 km. Have fun! Don’t deprive yourself of this additional power and smoothness for such a small difference, especially since the GDI engine is much livelier. However, if your budget only allows you to get the Atkinson engine, it’s not too bad either, albeit a tad boring.

The 2017 Forte’s ride is just as dull as the 2016 Forte. Driving modes that only change the gears and the sensitivity of the accelerator aren’t sufficient to spark excitement.

The Forte’s problem is that it tries to do everything at the same time. However, all segments feature champion cars. You can’t claim to be a dynamic car if you aren’t one: it’s just that simple.

Hyundai has just announced an upcoming sport version of the Elantra that will have more than 200 horsepower, and something similar should follow at Kia. In the meantime, the 2017 Forte, the sedan at least, is not a bad car at all. It does everything well, but doesn’t excel at anything.

Share on Facebook

More on the subject

First Drives2016 Honda Civic: Honda's Four-Door Neuralizer
Sometimes you pick yourself right up after a stumble. Sometimes it takes a little longer. When Honda whiffed with the redesign of its - let's face it - flagship Civic in 2012, it followed up with a quick re-do the following year in a bid to soothe the backlash from …
Test Drives2015 Mazda3 GT: Waiting For The Next MazdaSpeed3
Last year’s complete overhaul of the Mazda3 made it a more sophisticated, somewhat more mature model. It won numerous prestigious awards, not to mention being named “ 2015 Best Compact Car ” by The Car Guide. We like the Mazda3 primarily for its style and dynamic ride, two characteristics that …
First Drives2017 Hyundai Elantra: Taking the Honda Civic Head On
For years, the Honda Civic has been Canada’s top-selling vehicle, but the Hyundai Elantra is hot on its heels. In fact, the Korean car very nearly stole the first-place title two years ago. It’s easy to understand why crowning the category is so important to the Elantra. In response to …
ParisAll-new Kia Rio to make Global Debut in Paris
After being on the market since 2012, the current-generation Rio subcompact is due for a redesign, and a completely new model will be presented at the upcoming Mondial de l’automobile in Paris next month. Only design sketches have been released by Kia so far, but they reveal what should be …
ParisFirst pictures of the 2018 Kia Rio
Last week, we showed you sketches of the redesigned Rio subcompact, and now, Kia just released a few images of the actual vehicle that will make its global debut at the Mondial de l’automobile in Paris at the end of the month. The new Kia Rio, which will be badged …
Paris2018 Kia Rio Five-Door Bows in Paris
PARIS, France – Although subcompact car sales are struggling in Canada, the Rio is Kia’s best-selling model on a global scale. The current generation has been around since 2011, and although the car has generally aged well, it was time for a change. The new Rio will arrive next spring …
Los Angeles2017 Kia Soul Gets a Turbocharged Engine
Among the many changes Kia is applying to its subcompact Soul crossover, the most interesting one could very well be the addition of a turbocharged engine in the top-range SX trim, which was introduced at this year’s Los Angeles Auto Show. Matched to a seven-speed, dual-clutch automated gearbox, the turbo …
Spotlight on2017 Kia Niro: We’re Driving it This Week
The Toyota Prius is the most successful hybrid vehicle on the North-American market, and that obviously makes a lot of rival automakers jealous. There’s an opportunity for peddling hybrid cars in trendy areas such as California, and Hyundai and Kia are ready to challenge the Prius with a one-two punch.
First Drives2017 Kia Niro: The Troublemaker
SAN ANTONIO, Texas – What’s great about a hybrid is that we can drive it like a normal car, and it will magically provide us with lower fuel bills. No need to plug it in or calculate the distance of our commutes, all we have to do is fill a …